First fish
By Gary Borger

opened a bit, the gravelly stream bank supported sweet smelling grasses and the purple-blue flowers of wild cranesbill. And everywhere, there was the faint terpene smell of ponderosa pine and douglas fir.

We slept in. Breakfast was a lazy affair around a cheerful campfire. Days were spent exploring, photographing, throwing rocks, tying flies, and just being alive. Each evening, high above the river and twinkling like a million stars in the fading light, a throng of mayflies in nuptial dance would play out their last rites of life. As the shadows would crawl inexorably across the river to scale the eastern wall of the canyon, the tiny insects would drop to the surface in numbers beyond imagining.

I would rig two rods, and casting with one, hook a fiery rainbow or deep-fighting whitefish. Then I'd hand the rod to Jason.

"When the fish pulls, you let go of the reel," I told Jason, "and when it stops pulling, you crank.," The instructions were simple, and Jason followed them carefully. When he'd get a fish in close, I'd cast with the second rod and hook another eager fish. Then, we'd trade rods. And thus it would go for over an hour, trading rods and chattering uncontrollably in our excitement. Nancy would fish nearby and offer encouragement to Jason. When I became eager to fish, she would help Jason. He became very adept at playing fish.

It was with reluctance that we moved on. On to a camp high in the hills above Bozeman and nestled in the conifers along tiny Squaw Creek. It was another slice of the Garden. Deer came through camp and Canadian jays visited regularly to steal the pieces of bread we left on the table. And of course, there were the fish. Not large ones, but many. Every pocket contained one or two and they were always on the alert for food. On the second day at the camp, we decided to take two trout for our evening meal.

At the first pool, as I was tying on a Red Brown Nymph, I saw a fish take something just under the surface. Jason and I were well hidden by the vegetation and the high bank behind us, so I was sure the fish would continue to feed. Quickly I pulled several feet of line from the reel and prepared to cast. But then I thought, "Why not let Jason try. It would be fun to see what he does." He'd never cast before, but he had obviously developed a mental concept of getting the line out.

It's a good thing I can duck fast. His two-handed whipping motion tossed the fly somewhere, and as I tried to spot exactly where, I saw the flash of the fish. I knew it had taken the fly. Calmly I screamed, "You've got him Jason, you've got him." Responding to the cool, reassuring tone of my voice, all of Jason's training evaporated, and he hoisted on the rod with all his weight, falling back against the gravelly bank and sending the thirteen-inch rainbow high into the alders behind us.

Though I remember many fishing days from my early childhood, I can't remember the first fish I caught by myself. Maybe that's why I have such bright memories of Jason's first fish. But then again, maybe not. After all, what father has ever looked into the loving, radiant face of his child and not seen himself openly admired there? And what fly fishing father has ever shared that first fish and not felt all the years rush away, leaving him standing there naked in the emotions of his own youth? It's been said that we can never go back, but I wonder, I wonder.

Gary Borger is the author of several books on fly fishing, including his latest Presentation. He teaches biology at the University of Wisconsin/Wausau and has produced several videos on fly fishing.


This is a story about the special relationship between a fly fishing father and his son. It could just as well be about mother and son because my wife, Nancy, also fly fishes and has contributed strongly to Jason's development as an angler. Perhaps in the reading of this story, you may catch a glimpse of yourself or of someone you know; perhaps you will find a useful bit of information. But above all, I hope you will discover the great joys in sharing our fly fishing heritage with the ones we love.

Other fathers buy their new-born sons baseball mitts. I didn't. Fly fishing fathers buy their new-born sons fly rods. I didn't. I didn't for a very good reason: I wanted Jason to be what Jason wanted to be. I longed, no, I ached, with desire to hustle him into fly fishing. But children, I kept reminding myself, are not ours to mold into imperfect carbon copies of ourselves; they are ours to mold into the best they can become. We need to feel them out, find their strengths and their weaknesses, and then help them accentuate the positive. No, I decided, Jason will want fly fishing for Jason, not because I've pushed him into it. And so I put away those powerful, instinctive urges to rush out and buy, buy, buy.

Perhaps, though, there was more molding than either Nancy or I had intended. After all, we had both hunted, fished, camped, and canoed all our lives. Nancy's father had taken her fishing, and through the gift of a fly tying kit, had encouraged her to tie her own flies. One of my courting presents to Nancy had been a fly rod I'd custom built for her. Any child of ours was predestined to a life revolving around fly fishing.

The summer before Jason was born, Nancy and I foraged for wild foods, camped, fished, and hunted. The summer after Jason was born, we continued our outdoor activities; Jason went along. Always in safety, always with either mom or dad in close attendance. When I fished, Nancy watched Jason; when Nancy fished, I watched Jason. When we caught a fish, Jason would touch it and watch it intently. That fall, Nancy shot the biggest buck either of us has ever seen in the wild.
Jason was twenty-two months old when he made his first real connection between the act of fishing and the fish. We had gone to fish the August Pseudocloeon hatch in Black Earth Creek near Cross Plains, Wisconsin. With the hatch came a startlingly heavy rise of fish. Not large ones, but many. And they took the fly eagerly.

I was fishing and Nancy and Jason were walking nearby. They came close to the stream just as I hooked a little brown trout. I stuck the rod in Jason's hand and told him to grab the reel handle and crank. With the rod butt against his round little stomach, he cranked away, totally absorbed by the process and totally oblivious of the fish. Suddenly the fish jumped and splashed about on the surface, and Jason realized that it was somehow attached to the rod. If I close my eyes, I can still see the light come on in that little face and hear the squeal of delight. Yes, perhaps there was more molding than we had intended.

The next summer we went west, certainly to marvel at the glory of the mountains, certainly to fish. In the early days of the trip we camped and fished along the Smith River in central Montana. To us it was Eden. The river slid along between walls of rock, gurgling in the undercuts and tugging at the sides of boulders calved from the stone above. In places where the canyon

To the top of the next column


copyright Midwest Fly Fishing Magazine 1999